Is the influence of the farm lobby weakening?

 The Financial Times has a major article this morning on the CAP as discussions take place on the next iteration of the CAP.   And who is in charge as farm commissioner?  A farmer from Luxembourg who went to university in France.  The Grand Duchy is always seen as susceptible to French influence.

I reproduce some highlights from the article below but add some comments of my own in square brackets.

On May 1, decades of resistance by the agricultural lobby were broken when the trade deal Mercosur came into effect. Member states earlier voted narrowly to apply the pact, albeit with significant concessions to assuage the farmers and their powerful special-interest groups. European Commission president Ursula von der Leyen exercised her power to over-rule legal challenges to the deal to ensure it came into provisional force.

It was a moment that suggested the long-held power of the farmers could be weakening. Through political protection and heavy subsidies, European farming has been designed not only to secure food supplies but also to preserve a rural way of life.  [But the future of many rural areas may not be principally in farming but in tourism.  Better broadband connection is vital.]

The result is a sector that remains dominated by small family farms even as agriculture elsewhere in the world has consolidated and industrialised. But the Mercosur deal has shown that the model may be coming under strain, just as policymakers are debating the future of the subsidy regime that underpins it.   [But the deal has been watered down and took quarter of a century to negotiate].

Farming groups say trade deals and other reforms threaten Europe’s food security at a time of growing geopolitical risk and just as farmers come under even more pressure as the Gulf crisis forces up fuel and fertiliser prices.   [It’s a good time for farmers to bang the food security drum].

But supporters of reform to the system argue that Europe’s priority has to be competing in this new geopolitical world, rather than shielding farmers from market forces with a safety net of subsidies.

Some believe these heavy subsidies are slowing down market-driven restructuring that could replace failing family farms with more efficient, large-scale agribusinesses — as is happening already in parts of southern Europe. The impact on overall food production would be limited, they say.   [But the idea of the family farm has sentimental appeal to urban voters].

Smaller farms are also seen by industry groups as central to Europe’s rural identity. Organisations such as Italy’s biggest farm lobby Coldiretti argue that these holdings sustain not just local economies but landscapes, traditions and food cultures that define much of the continent.  [High quality foodstuffs are niche products that can command a price well above that commanded by commodities.  Many consumers are ‘foodies’ interested in cooking and provenance].

But some experts argue the risk to food security is overstated. Recent studies by the EU’s Joint Research Centre show that if the CAP were removed, agricultural production would only reduce by just over 5 per cent.

“Fertile good land is not going to be left idle if we don’t pay subsidies to farmers,” Alan Matthews, professor of European agricultural policy at Trinity College Dublin, told the Pink ‘Un. He says that to maximise food production and reduce subsidies, the EU needs bigger farms. But that goes against the grain of popular opinion and national culture.   [I have recently been working on a co-authored essay with him].

The current moment “raises interesting questions about whether family farming is the way to continue the structure in the future”, Matthews told the FT, “not only when farmers have to raise their crops but have to be accountants, they have to be vets and environmentalists and work drones and all this stuff. To expect anyone to be even medium level in all these skills is a little too much.”

Institutional investors move in

As many family farmers are selling up, institutional investors are moving in. Spain and Portugal, which already supply a large share of Europe’s fruit, vegetables and olive oil, have become a focal point, where many see an opportunity to expand and modernise farming.   Data from global real estate adviser CBRE shows more than €4.2bn was invested in Iberian agribusiness between 2022 and 2024, with institutional investors accounting for roughly half of that total.

“Until 10-15 years ago, the agricultural asset class wasn’t a prime consideration in investors’ portfolios,” Javier Uribarren, partner at Trifolium Farms told the leading business paper.  This business acquires and manages agricultural land on behalf of institutional investors across Iberia, focusing on permanent crops such as olives, almonds and citrus.

Increasingly, however, it has become more attractive as “an inflation hedge” and as “an asset that is uncorrelated from others” in a typical portfolio, he commented. The attraction is not just the land itself, but how the sector is changing. “There’s a natural consolidation of a sector that was very much driven by family ownership and that is the succession of family ownership into institutional investors, private equity, pension funds etc,” he added, explaining that farms are often too small to compete and in many cases there is no one to take them over.

 Investors are betting that bigger farms work better. “Everything that we do is mechanised,” Uribarren says. “Unless you have the necessary scale . . . it’s not profitable.” Larger operations can invest in irrigation, new planting systems and technology that smaller farms cannot afford.

This will make it easier for the EU to compete with more industrialised producers such as Brazil or Australia, where agriculture operates at greater scale and with fewer subsidies. But Europe’s farmers are unlikely to go down without a manure-slinging fight first.   [Expect more angry demonstrations in Brussels and member states].

 

Weather in Soutrhern Europe hits food supplies

Fence to keep out wild boar on a family member's farm in Spain

Voters and consumers particularly react to food price inflation which has remained relatively high.  I certainly notice it on my trips to the supermarket and I am not a poorer consumer.   The least well off spend a great portion of their budgets on food and often have to rely on food banks.

One of my children has a small retirement farm in Spain and tells me that January has been unusually cold and wet, albeit that has replenished their water source.   The almond trees do seem to have blossomed more or less on schedule.

A lot of big fruit and vegetable producers in the UK decamp to Spain for the winter.   The carbon footprint of growing tomatoes under heated glass is greater.

A wave of extreme rain and flooding across the Mediterranean countries and north Africa has battered the winter growing regions that feed Europe, disrupting supplies of fruit and vegetables and threatening food price rises. Spain, Portugal, Morocco and parts of Italy and Greece function as Europe’s winter “pantry”, exporting tomatoes, cucumbers, avocados, peppers, berries and citrus fruit northwards when domestic output is limited.

But extensive damage to crops and infrastructure in recent weeks could quickly ripple through wholesale markets and supermarket supply chains, warn economists. “When you have the types of floods that we’re seeing in Europe and north Africa, combined also with the very wet winter here in the UK . . . there’s no way around it: we’ll see the pressure on vegetable and fruit prices,” David Barmes, policy fellow at the London School of Economics’ Centre for Economic Transition Expertise told the Financial Times.

Spain, which recorded its wettest January in 25 years, has already recorded damage to 22,000 hectares of agricultural land, according to insurance association Agroseguro. Luis Planas, Spain’s agriculture minister, told the Pink ‘Un that the affected area could “nearly double” once assessments were complete. The ruin extends beyond crops to irrigation systems, farm machinery and rural roads, complicating harvesting and distribution even where produce survives.

The concentration of European winter fruit and vegetable supply in a handful of regions makes markets particularly sensitive to weather shocks. In January last year, Spain accounted for more than 70 per cent of UK sweet pepper imports and 65 per cent of cucumbers, while Morocco supplied more than a third of British strawberry and raspberry imports, according to UK trade data.

“The biggest, probably most proximate impact [from the recent weather] is the impact on fresh produce from Spain and Morocco,” Tom Lancaster at the Energy and Climate Intelligence Unit, a UK-based think-tank told the FT. “If supply tightens, buyers may find themselves competing for smaller volumes,” he said. “You might also see an impact on quality: fruit damaged by heavy rain doesn’t travel or store as well.”

The Netherlands imports 35-40 per cent of its fresh vegetables from Spain, Morocco and Portugal, which together also provide 15-20 per cent of its fresh fruit imports during January and February, according to ING.    (Perhaps that explains why there are so many Dutch expats in my daughter’s area of Spain, indeed my great-granddaughter has a decent command of Dutch).

 In Andalusia, one of Spain’s main agricultural regions, farmers’ association Asaja estimates that 20 per cent of all production has been lost. In one province alone, Córdoba, Asaja said losses totalled €700mn, with olive groves accounting for €550mn of that sum and further damage to cereals and citrus. Last week Pedro Sánchez, Spain’s controversial prime minister, visited the storm-hit town of Huétor Tájar, west of Granada, where the mayor explained that 80 per cent of its population depended directly or indirectly on the region’s asparagus production. With harvesting due to begin within weeks, mayor Fernando Delgado said that as much as a third of the crop remained underwater.

The adverse weather across Andalusia and other major growing regions in southern Europe meant “prices would be higher year on year”, Thijs Geijer, a senior economist covering food and agriculture at ING told the leading economics and business paper, adding that consumers would see fewer discounts. But he noted that the effect on inflation data could be muted in the Netherlands, where the affected products carry little weight in the consumer price index.

 Barmes said that the latest storms were part of a wider pattern of climate shocks feeding into food price inflation. His recent research has shown that the gap between UK and euro area food inflation in recent months was largely driven by a small number of climate‑sensitive items — including chocolate and olive oil — some of which carry a much heavier weight in the UK shopping basket, leaving British consumers more affected when extreme weather hits.

“To me, there’s little doubt that we’ll see pressure on food prices later in the year, even if some of it will be more short term,” he told the FT. “It’s very difficult to substitute away from Spain and Morocco in particular for certain parts of the winter vegetable basket, so I think we’ll see that [impact] quite soon, and then later, we’ll probably see effects also on fruit, and then also on meat and dairy . . . and olive oil.”

Central banks have begun acknowledging the influence of extreme weather on inflation dynamics. In its August 2025 monetary policy report, the Bank of England noted that climate-linked disruptions were contributing to higher UK food prices and complicating efforts to return inflation to its 2 per cent target. Governments have pledged support for affected farmers through insurance payouts and EU crisis reserve funds linked to the bloc’s Common Agricultural Policy.

Spain has vowed to give farmers €2.2bn in direct aid and spend €600mn on rebuilding infrastructure.  But economists say the broader concern is structural. “I think we’re really seeing that this is not a one-off,” said Barmes. “These types of climate-related supply disruptions are becoming more frequent, severe, and geographically widespread.”